Misclassifying an employee as exempt from overtime is one of the more expensive mistakes a small business can make, and it's often made with good intentions — putting someone on salary because it feels more professional, or assuming a management-sounding title automatically means no overtime is owed. It doesn't work that way. Exempt status depends on specific legal tests, not on job title or how the employee is paid, and getting it wrong can mean owing years of back overtime once it's caught.
The Default Is Non-Exempt
Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), every employee is presumed non-exempt — meaning entitled to overtime pay for hours worked over 40 in a week — unless the employer can show they clearly meet one of a limited set of exemptions. The burden is on the business to prove exempt status, not on the employee to prove they're owed overtime. That framing matters: when in doubt, the safer legal position is non-exempt.
Salary Alone Doesn't Make Someone Exempt
This is the most common misunderstanding. Paying someone a salary instead of an hourly wage is necessary for most exemptions, but it is not sufficient on its own. An employee also has to earn above a minimum salary threshold (which is set federally and updated periodically, and some states set a higher threshold) and their actual job duties have to meet the specific requirements of an exemption category. A salaried administrative assistant doing largely clerical work is very likely still non-exempt, regardless of the salary label.
The Main Exemption Categories
Most small business exemptions fall into a few standard categories, each with its own duties test:
- Executive exemption: the employee regularly supervises two or more full-time employees and has real authority over hiring, firing, or promotion decisions.
- Administrative exemption: the employee's primary duty involves office work directly related to management or business operations, and involves the exercise of independent judgment on significant matters.
- Professional exemption: the role requires advanced knowledge in a field of science or learning, typically acquired through specialized education (think licensed professionals), or is a recognized creative/artistic role.
Each category has more nuance than a one-line summary can capture, and job titles like "manager" or "coordinator" don't automatically qualify someone — what matters is what the person actually does day to day.
Why Misclassification Gets Expensive
If a non-exempt employee is misclassified as exempt, the business typically owes back overtime for up to two or three years (depending on whether the violation is found to be willful), plus in many cases liquidated damages equal to the unpaid overtime itself, plus potential penalties. And this rarely surfaces as an isolated problem — if one employee in a role was misclassified, everyone in that same role likely was too, which turns a single complaint into a much larger liability.
Don't Forget State Law
Federal law sets the floor, not the ceiling. A number of states have higher minimum salary thresholds for exempt status, additional daily overtime rules, or stricter duties tests than the federal FLSA. A classification that's defensible under federal rules can still be wrong under your state's law, so classification decisions need to be checked against both.
When to Get Help
Classification questions are genuinely fact-specific — the right answer depends on what an employee actually does, not what their offer letter says. If you're creating a new role, changing someone's responsibilities, or simply unsure whether an existing classification is correct, it's worth having an employment attorney or HR professional review it. A short consultation is far cheaper than years of back pay for a role that was never actually exempt.
Comments
Post a Comment